Manchester United have finally hired the manager they have been linked with for almost a decade. Mauricio Pochettino started work as head coach on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, five days after the club confirmed the appointment. He replaces Michael Carrick and has signed a deal of about two and a half years, according to Sports Illustrated.
The timing is brutal. United sit 18th in the Premier League with one league win, and his first two games are away at Liverpool and away at Sporting in the Champions League. Here are the five questions that will decide whether this is a fresh start or another false dawn.
1. Why did United move on from Carrick so fast?
Only a few months ago, Carrick looked like the answer. He took United to third place last season and back into the Champions League. This season fell apart almost at once. By the time he was dismissed on 12 November, United had won just three games in all competitions.
The underlying numbers were just as worrying. Opta's analysts at The Analyst found United were running 112.5 km per match, the second-lowest total in the league. Only four teams pressed the ball less often, and all four of them see much more of the ball than United do. When a squad stops running, boards stop waiting. This is now the eighth permanent managerial change at Old Trafford since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013.
2. What did United pay to get him?
Pochettino was not a free agent. He was in charge of the United States national team, and had signed a new four-year contract in August 2026 that ran to the 2030 World Cup. United reportedly paid around £7.4 million to U.S. Soccer to release him, plus roughly £5 million for his backroom staff.
That is a big outlay for a club in a relegation fight, and it tells you how long United have wanted him. Ferguson famously met Pochettino for lunch in 2016, and he was on the shortlist again in 2021 and 2022 before the club chose other coaches.
3. Does his record justify the hype?
The case for Pochettino starts at Tottenham. Between 2014 and 2019 he turned Spurs into a top-four regular, with three straight top-three finishes. In 2016–17 his side scored 86 league goals, conceded only 26 and went unbeaten at home. He then led Spurs to the 2019 Champions League final.
The case against him is about trophies. Spurs won nothing under him, and he has lost four major finals:
| Season | Competition | Team | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2014–15 | League Cup final | Tottenham | Lost |
| 2018–19 | Champions League final | Tottenham | Lost 2–0 to Liverpool |
| 2023–24 | League Cup final | Chelsea | Lost |
| 2025 | Gold Cup final | USA | Lost |
His only silverware came at Paris Saint-Germain: the Coupe de France in 2020–21 and Ligue 1 in 2021–22, with Lionel Messi and Kylian Mbappé in the squad. His single season at Chelsea in 2023–24 ended in sixth place, with a Premier League record of 105 yellow cards.
With the USA at the 2026 World Cup, he beat Paraguay, Australia and Bosnia before a 4–1 loss to Belgium in the round of 16. Data from that tournament shows his side pressed high and aggressively. That is exactly what United's current squad has not been doing.
4. What has to change first?
Effort. Pochettino's teams are built on running, pressing and fitness, and he treats work rate as non-negotiable. A squad near the bottom of the league for distance covered is the opposite of what he wants. Expect tougher training, a higher defensive line over time, and more minutes for young players who will run. Developing youth was a big part of his work at Southampton and Spurs, and it is one reason Ferguson has long rated him.
The bigger risk is time. He arrives during an international break, so most of the first-team players have been away with their countries. He will have only a few sessions with the full squad before Anfield.
5. What comes next, for United and the USMNT?
United's fixture list does Pochettino no favours. First comes Liverpool at Anfield this weekend, then a trip to Sporting in the Champions League on 25 November. Even a draw in Lisbon could matter for the club's European hopes, given how poorly the campaign has started.
The U.S. national team has its own problem. It lost its coach in the middle of the Concacaf Nations League, though the next competitive matches are not until March 2027. Reports say U.S. Soccer views Pep Guardiola as its top target. Nashville SC's B.J. Callaghan and U-23 coach Steve Cherundolo have also been mentioned.
The verdict
Pochettino is the right kind of manager for what United need right now: a coach who demands intensity and trusts young players. But the problems at Old Trafford run deeper than any one coach, and every manager since Ferguson has left with his reputation damaged. Pochettino's long-term success will depend on the club backing him in the transfer market and giving him time.
For now, the target is simple: climb out of the bottom three before Christmas. Do that, and the most famous "nearly man" in United's managerial history might finally get his chance to build something.
What do you think: can Pochettino turn Manchester United around this season? Tell us in the comments, and follow SportsLNV for live updates from Anfield.
Sources: LiveScore / GOAL · Sports Illustrated · The Analyst




